I felt like an absolute old woman this year in terms of music. Standing out on my metaphorical lawn, shaking my fist and shouting “You young whippersnappers call that limp electro-pop crap MUSIC? By golly, I should tan your hides for your impudence and/or gullibility…”
It was not a good year for music. Trying to gather together a list of my top ten albums proved a little fruitless – there were some good albums, but very few great albums, and it was frankly a disappointing year for some bands that ordinarily I can rarely find fault with.
So instead of presenting a straight forward top albums list, I’m going to mix it up a little into more of an awards night ceremony. So dust off your frocks and sparklies, make room in your handbags to make off with the free liquor, it’s the 2008 Hayley Music Awards! All winners receive half a biro.
(Some awards are clearly self-explanatory; others I will provide some half-arsed attempt at reasoning.)
The Most Enthusiastic Of Encouragement Award
Guy Blackman – Adult Baby
Debut albums are tricky beasties. Either they are instant successes, immediately clutched unto bosoms and come to haunt the musicians who created them by constantly reappearing throughout their career, accompanied by the deathly phrase “Yeah, but it’s not as good as their first album”; or, they are quiet affairs, where the listener can divine pockets of promise, hints that indicate a potential future brilliance, obscured either by lack of production funds or simple inexperience. Adult Baby is of the latter, a lovely little package of potential promise, working as a nice introduction to Blackman’s work, yet it isn’t perfect, and leaves you itching for someone to throw scads of money at him in order to fully achieve the musical vision obviously trying to break out. Hopefully, album number two should be a doozy. Be expectant.
The I’ll Forgive This Lacklustre Effort On the Strength Of Previous Work, But Don’t Do It Again Award
Augie March – Watch Me Disappear
I have always dreaded the thought that one day Augie March might possibly put out an album that I could not adore. They are the band that I have loved the longest, when, as a fourteen year old who had just discovered the existence of Triple J, I heard “Asleep in Perfection” and had my mind and heart musically blown for the first time, an experience that has never been repeated to the same earth-shattering extent. The journey that I have travelled with Augie March since that day is my most treasured – each album, each song, each note and word infinately precious and containing worlds that I have explored countless times. Each Augie March album – Sunset Studies, Strange Bird, Moo You Bloody Choir – is an album any other band would kill thousands for in order to call it their own creation. That one band produced all three isn’t just phenomenal, it borders on the obscene. That one band should be so ethereally talented, it should cause other musicians to hang up their instruments in pitiful defeat.
I guess I shouldn’t be surprised that there had to be a glitch sooner or later. It’s not that Watch Me Disappear is a bad album, per se; indeed, if any other band had produced it, it would be singled out as the peak of their career. It’s just as a specifically Augie March album, it fails to live up to their previous dizzyingly high precedents.
My first reaction in listening to the album was “Have they released the demos by mistake?” The songs have an incompleteness to them, full of empty spaces that feel as if they are waiting to be filled. Songs segue in and out of each other without much change – you’ll be listening to one then, lose your focus, then realise that three other songs have gone past without you noticing.
That’s not to say that all the songs are completely forgettable. Lead single “Pennywhistle” is a cheery little number with a darkly lyrical soul, an ode to rapidly dimishing youth and the endless, tireless pursuit of the Black Dog. “Becoming Bryn” continues the horror film themes of Moo’s “Thin Captain Crackers” (“If you see me rising up through the floor with unblinking eyes, run, run, run, run, run!”). And final song “The Devil In Me”, well, it’s up there with the best of Augie March. Just a shame that so much of the album doesn’t rise up to the same standard.
For previous services in the name of Australian music and the complete betterment of my soul, Augie March are given a creative pardon for Watch Me Disappear. But don’t do it again.
The I Love You Guys, But Really, What The HELL Were You Thinking? Award
Tilly & the Wall – O
See, it started off all lovely and gorgeous. Opening track Tall Tall Grass is simultaneously vintage Tilly and a sinuous tease, hinting at a lyrical deepness, a touch of rough, distorted guitar towards the end unobtrusive, fitting. It is gentle, very slightly wistful, sad. It holds such promise. It lures you onwards.
ONWARDS INTO DOOM!
Well, doom’s probably far too strong a word. But it’s disappointing none the less. Pot Kettle Black blows my mind in all manner of wrong ways because I have no idea what it is trying to say and how on earth this band came to write it. The majority of the album seems to be the band trying not to be Tilly & the Wall, trying to skew into something musically harder that doesn’t quite work. Most of the album ends up kind of messy and confused-sounding, and missing what gives Tilly it’s soul – those gorgeous twining harmonies that soar about and above everything else, that cheeky irreverence, the delightful dancy poppiness, and the aching sincerity. Tall Tall Grass has it, Dust Me Off has it in glorious spades, but it is sorely lacking in the rest, obscured by noise and ill-advised experimentation. I really hate having to give such a poor surmation of the album, particularly when I love the band like crazy – they are truly one of the most original and joyously inspiring outfits running around at the moment, and maybe the casual or first-time listener wouldn’t be as scathing as I have been. I may just have expected too much.
The I Wish This Album Had Been Released In 2008 So’s I Could Award It Best Album, ’Cos It’s All I’ve Been Listening To All Year Award
The New Pornographers – Challengers
The Best New Scenesters Who Will Hopefully Last Because Boy Howdy Are They A Lot Of Fun Award
Vampire Weekend – Vampire Weekend
The I Didn’t Realise I Needed A Neo Doo-Wop ’50s Band In My Life, Thank You For Fulfilling A Desire I Didn’t Know I Had Award
Little Red – Listen to Little Red
The You Guys Just Keep Getting Better And Better Award
Mates of State – Re-Arrange Us
I loved MoS’s previous album Bring It Back with a fierce burning love – “Like U Crazy” is still one of my most beloved songs ever – and I was anxious when Re-Arrange Us appeared, leading to a feverent pleading with the music gods – “please let this be completely awesome”. I had no need to be worried. From the gorgeous opener “Get Better” I was sold. Utterly delightful (and “Now” is totally my favourite song to sing in the car; I must look a fright to other drivers happily chanting “nownownownownownow” at the top of my lungs).
The Say Goodbye To The Whining Fangirls/boys And Welcome In The Golden Era Of Your Career Award
Conor Oberst – Conor Oberst
Here’s an important announcement from a die-hard Bright Eyes fan, ie me. I hate die-hard Bright Eyes fans. Because not only do they taint my enjoyment of the most emo-tastic band in history with their fevered whinings, their insistence on utterly bagging anything Conor Oberst produces out of Bright Eyes makes me want to scream and break things. Because this album shits on any album he ever did under the Bright Eyes name. Especially Fevers & Mirrors (god, how I hate Fevers & Mirrors thanks to the crazy fans).
This solo effort is the direct descendant of the past two Bright Eyes albums, I’m Wide Awake, It’s Morning and Cassadaga, and with Conor Oberst you kind of get a fuller understanding of where those two albums were trying to go. This is Conor at his musical height, unfettered by baggage and unfeasibly high expectation. You get the impression that he’s writing from a purer place, a place that’s not concerned with listener reception or arm chair critics, and certainly not the crazies who still expect a 28 year old to be the teenage saviour of their own adolescence. He’s writing for himself now. And if writing for himself and under his own name results in songs like ”Lenders In The Temple”, “I Don’t Wanna Die (In The Hospital)” and the utterly sublime “Cape Canaveral” (the best song Conor has ever written, hands down), if he chooses never to write under the name of Bright Eyes again, I will greet it as a book closed for all the right reasons.
The Sweetest, Most Joyous Of Sounds, Oh Lordy I Wish This Band Put Out A New Album Every Month Award
The Lucksmiths – First Frost
No matter how long you have to wait, a Lucksmiths album always delivers. Utter perfection, especially “Lament of the Chiming Wedgebill”.
The I Want To Marry Jack White Award
The Raconteurs – Consolers of the Lonely
I mean really, who doesn’t want to marry Jack White? The man’s a sexy musical genius.
and finally
The Best Album Of The Year Award
Islands – Arm’s Way
I only came into possession of this album because I am cheap. I was faffing around in my local record store, and whatever album I had intended to purchase wasn’t in stock. Reluctant to leave without anything (which is my bane in both record and book stores), I started to gravitate towards discs with discount stickers on them. Drawn towards the gorgeous album art, and prompted further by the thought “Wasn’t one of the fellas in this in The Unicorns as well?”, I impulse purchased.
I now know that the fact this album was discounted was a grave crime, and that I possibly made off with the greatest bargain of my life. Because it has eaten into my soul; a little burrowing creature squirming itself into my deepest, darkest mind-places waiting to explode at key moments with exhilerating, blissful bursts of absolute feeling and magic. Such perfect moments: The first scornful drawl of “Kids don’t know shit…” in the song of the same name. The triumphant scream in Life in Jail - “Besides, there’s nothing to live for! unless you live a little more like you’re going to die….oohhhhhhhhhh!” The coda to I Feel Evil Creeping In, which I, in an increasingly paranoid manner, believe refers directly to me – “When I behave, nobody cares. When I behave badly nobody dare cross me.”
I cannot explain with mere human words how much awesome this album contains. Do whatever you need in order to get your hands on it.